Project Details
Project
CIEL Sustainable Finance Framework Second Party Opinion (2025)
Client
CIEL Limited
Project Type
Sustainability Bond/Loan; Sustainability Linked Bond or Note; Sustainability Linked Loan;
Industry Group
Diversified Financials
Use of Proceeds
Renewable energy; Energy efficiency; Green buildings; Water/waste water management; Pollution prevention and control; Natural resources/land use management; Sustainable forestry; Employment generation and Socio-economic empowerment; Access to essential services;
Location
Mauritius
Evaluation Date
Aug 2025
Evaluation Summary
CIEL Limited has developed the CIEL Sustainable Finance Framework, dated August 2025, under which it intends to issue or obtain green, social and sustainability bonds and loans, sustainability linked bonds and loans. The green, social and sustainability bonds and loans will finance projects in Uganda, Kenya, Madagascar, Mauritius, India and Bangladesh under six environmental and four social categories. The financial characteristics of the sustainability-linked bonds and loans, namely coupon or margin step-up or step-down and early redemption premium will be tied to the achievement of the sustainability performance targets (SPTs) for three key performance indicators (KPIs): i) Women Empowerment and Gender Equality; ii) Renewable Energy; and iii) Water Consumption.
Use of Proceeds:
We have assessed the overall Sustainability Contribution of the Framework as Significant, based on the average Sustainability Contribution of the Framework’s ten use of proceeds categories. As per our methodology, we have applied equal weighting across categories.
CIEL intends to finance environmental and social expenditures in Renewable Energy, Energy Efficiency, Green Buildings, Sustainable Water and Wastewater Management, Pollution Prevention and Control, Natural Resources, Sustainable Forestry, Employment Generation and Programmes, Access to Essential Services, Preservation of Cultural Heritage and Gender Equality and Women Empowerment.
Under Renewable Energy, CIEL will finance low-carbon energy generation along with associated battery energy storage systems, which are critical to achieving zero-emissions energy systems. Energy Efficiency investments will include replacing existing equipment and technologies with the best available alternatives in the market to lead to a minimum 20% reduction in energy consumption. It may also include switching from heavy fuel oil boilers to biogas boilers and installing waste heat recovery systems. These projects significantly support the low-carbon transition. Under the Green Buildings, CIEL will fund the construction and renovation of residential and non-residential buildings that meet global sustainability certifications or reduce energy and water use. Although new buildings constructed on and after 1 January 2024 may still rely on fossil fuels, these investments are expected to significantly advance sectoral decarbonization. Sustainable Water and Wastewater Management projects will reduce leakages and improve infrastructure for water collection, treatment, distribution and reuse, making a strong contribution to water resource efficiency. Investments in Pollution Prevention and Control focus on waste management practices and air quality improvement systems, which are expected to have a significant contribution to waste and pollutants reduction. Natural Resources and Sustainable Forestry investments support sustainable agriculture techniques in cropping agriculture, afforestation, reforestation and biodiversity restoration, strongly contributing to ecosystem resilience.
Additionally, CIEL will invest in Employment Generation through loans and financial services provided to women-led and underserved microenterprises and SMEs. The Group will also finance the provision of healthcare services in countries with limited infrastructure and the preservation of cultural heritage sites of historical significance in Mauritius. While these projects may not be universally affordable or provide clearly defined financial benefits, they address unmet needs and are expected to significantly contribute to expanding access to essential services and safeguarding cultural heritage. CIEL’s financing towards gender equality and women empowerment will support leadership training, Equal-Salary certification and inclusive hiring, significantly helping to reduce workplace barriers and advance gender equity across its operations.
Sustainability Linked:
We have assessed the KPIs as follows: KPI 1 as Strong because it: i) represents a direct measure of a material social issue related to gender diversity across CIEL’s operations; ii) reflects a high scope of applicability; iii) follows a clear and consistent methodology; and iv) there are no applicable externally recognized benchmarks for this KPI, but it enables comparability across various industry players. KPI 2 as Adequate because it: i) represents an indirect measure of a material environmental issue related to GHG emissions across CIEL’s operations; ii) reflects a sufficient scope of applicability; iii) follows a clear and consistent methodology that is externally defined; and iv) there are no applicable externally recognized benchmarks for this KPI. KPI 3 as Strong because it: i) represents a direct measure of a material environmental issue related to water consumption within CIEL’s textile and hospitality operations; ii) reflects a high scope of applicability; iii) follows a clear and consistent methodology that is externally defined; and iv) there are no applicable externally recognized benchmarks for this KPI, but it enables comparability across various industry players.
In addition, all SPTs align with the Group’s sustainability strategy. We have assessed SPTs as follows: SPT 1.A as Moderately Ambitious given that it: i) is below past performance; ii) is above peer performance; and iii) cannot be compared against science-based trajectories, as there are currently no external benchmarks or pathways specific to gender diversity targets. SPT 1.B as Ambitious given that it: i) is aligned with past performance; ii) is above peer performance; and iii) cannot be compared against science-based trajectories, as there are currently no external benchmarks or pathways specific to gender diversity targets. SPT 1.C as Ambitious given that it: i) is above past performance; ii) is above peer performance; and iii) cannot be compared against science-based trajectories, as there are currently no external benchmarks or pathways specific to gender diversity targets. SPTs 2.A, 2.B and 2.C as Ambitious given that they: i) are aligned with past performance; ii) are above peer performance; and iii) cannot be compared against science-based decarbonization trajectories, as there are currently no relevant external benchmarks that cover the share of renewable energy in a company’s total energy mix beyond electricity consumption. SPTs 3.A, 3.B and 3.C as Moderately Ambitious given that they: i) are below past performance; ii) are above peer performance; and iii) cannot be compared against science-based trajectories, as there are currently no relevant external benchmarks or pathways specific to water consumption reduction targets.
We have assessed the Framework as Aligned with the Green Bond Principles 2025, Social Bond Principles 2025, Sustainability Bond Guidelines 2021, Green Loan Principles 2025, Social Loan Principles 2025, Sustainability-Linked Bonds Principles 2024 and Sustainability Linked Loan Principles 2025.