Skip to main content

Smart Beta ESG - The Next Big Thing in Asset Management?

Posted on September 28, 2018

Doug Morrow
Doug Morrow
Director Head of Portfolio Research

Smart beta is all the rage these days. According to data from Morningstar, global assets under management in smart beta strategies hit USD 1tn last year, up from USD 136bn in 2007.[i]

At the same time, investors have been piling assets into environmental, social and governance (ESG) strategies: global ESG assets under management have been estimated at USD 23tn, up 76% from 2012.

Smart beta and ESG may be two of the hottest trends in investment management, but little research has been done to understand how, if at all, these investment styles are mingling with each other.

To shed light on this question, we recently teamed up with Aberdeen Standard Investments and Oxford University on one of the world’s first dedicated smart beta ESG research projects. We consulted 85 investors across 21 countries and asked them pointed questions about their use of, and plans for, smart beta ESG – investment strategies that provide simultaneous exposure to risk premia and ESG criteria.

Early days for smart beta ESG

Our study reveals three key findings about smart beta ESG. First, and perhaps unsurprisingly, it’s early days for such strategies. Just 24% of investors reported a current allocation to smart beta ESG, with regional adoption rates ranging from 32% (Europe), to 19% (North America) and 11% for Asia-Pacific (APAC) investors. By any measure, smart beta ESG remains a highly specialized investment proposition.

Are any of your assets currently using a smart beta ESG strategy?

Negative screens predominate

Second, investors are using three broad approaches to implement smart beta ESG. The most common (62% of smart beta ESG strategies) is negative screens. Examples would include extending a screen on controversial weapons companies to smart beta mandates, dedicated funds or internally managed portfolios.

Another widely used technique (31% of smart beta ESG strategies) is what we termed “ESG metrics.” This approach entails blending conventional factors, such as value and momentum, with ESG metrics that have been found through quantitative testing to add incremental financial value. Investors in this camp largely cited environmental and corporate governance data.

The last approach is climate tilts. This specialized approach (about 7% of smart beta ESG strategies) involves adjusting the final weight of companies in a factor index based on climate change-related metrics, such as carbon emissions.

Lots of action behind the scenes

Finally, despite the low pick up of smart beta ESG, our research suggests that a substantial amount of research and testing is taking place behind the scenes. Nearly one-quarter (21%) of investors said that they expect to increase their allocation to smart beta ESG over the next one to two years.

Do you expect to increase your allocation to smart beta ESG strategies in the next 12-24 months?

Conclusion – more innovation expected

While decidedly nascent today, smart beta ESG could become the next big thing in the asset management world, as investors move to differentiate their smart beta offerings and pick up on the growing risk/return benefits of ESG integration. It is certainly an evolving space that we expect to monitor closely going forward.


[i] Morningstar uses the phrase “strategic beta,” which is slightly more expansive than what is typically referred to as “smart beta”.

Recent Content

GLP-1 Medications for Cosmetic Weight Loss and Diabetes | Sustainalytics

Why Looks Could Kill: An ESG Perspective on GLP-1 Medications for Cosmetic Weight Loss and Diabetes

GLP-1 medications' proven efficacy for weight loss caused global demand for these treatments to soar. While the heightened demand is promising for biopharmaceutical companies, it also introduces an array of ESG challenges that this article explores.

Cementing a Sustainable Future: Raw Materials Risk Management in the Construction Materials Industry

Explore trends in raw material use in construction, focusing on scarcity, environmental impact, and decarbonization. Learn about key risks and management strategies to address future challenges in the industry.

Semiconductor Fabs and Raw Materials: Strategies to Manage the Growing Risk of Supply Bottlenecks

The widespread adoption of computing applications, such as autonomous vehicles, artificial intelligence and 5G communication technology, is significantly boosting demand for semiconductors. This article looks at the underlying factors contributing to the semiconductor industry's resource strain and strategies to managing this growing risk.

Turning the Tide: Understanding Water Risks in the Oil and Gas Sector

Turning the Tide: Understanding Water Risks in the Oil and Gas Sector

Explore how climate change impacts water resources, posing risks to the oil and gas industry. Discover Morningstar Sustainalytics' new ESG Risk Ratings and strategies for sustainable water management.